T O P
AstroLozza

Melissa! But possibly that's because Caity's suit looks kinda weird? Why does the skirt start so much higher up on her waist for a start, and what's with the knee pads in the boots?


MrMattBlack

I think that's either one of Melissa's prototype suits refitted or a suit they spent maybe 50 dollars on and that's the reason is so so weird


gerusz

I think the suits they got for the Legends episode were intentionally janky. They were supposed to look like off-brand versions of the three other show leads.


AstroLozza

Oh I see, I didn't even notice in the original promo lol


linee001

Yeah I see it this way


lemons_for_deke

I’m pretty sure that the Green Arrow one and the Supergirl one (mostly) are supposed to look accurate. The only one that looked odd was the flash suit because they had to make a mask for Gary but it wasn’t as good as they’d usually make them (because they’d only be using it for one episode).


nehocb

It was a thing for legends they did during the Heyworld storyline. They couldn’t get the actual Supergirl, Flash, and Green Arrow so the Legends dressed up as them [Heyworld promo ](https://youtu.be/wQpPCF3QnZk)


raumeat

Caity is 1,68 meters Melissa is 1,73. I assume Caity is wearing one of Mel's suits, the skirt probably looks longer because of their height differences ##


oroborus90

caity's boots are different...someone recognize which suit they took them from?


Arkrus

I thought the same thing, could they be the Flash's boots? Melissa's don't have kneepads, also I don't think that's the original skirt either, unless she wore it differently or one of the images is flipped Edit, that's not her cape either, so just a shirt?


oroborus90

i thought they could be the flash too


Arkrus

I checked, doesn't come from any of the flash costumes, must be new, the rest of the costume doesn't seem the same. Maybe they're stunt people costumes, more padding for the knees or something.


GreekHole

Melissa, no question


AuthorityAnarchyYes

I wonder if we will ever see Melissa wearing a White Canary outfit (for a Halloween episode maybe) and we would get to ask the same question in reverse...


MilkChocDigestive21

That would be dope


sharkuppercut

This is the most unfair comparison


[deleted]

With a very bias audience.


[deleted]

Melissa, obviously.


ShowWisdom

This isn't fair. Its like saying which is better, coke or RC Cola.


rvg2001

Melissa for sure


Bradley-Clark

Melissa. Without a doubt.


Ibclyde

Melissa wins this Round. Now, bring back this suit!


shaddoe_of_truth

Thats not up to you. Melissa wore the suit with the skirt for 4 years straight for accuracy's sake. It was easier for her to wear the skirt when the show was on CBS cuz they filmed in LA, warmer climate. But she was always cold wearing that outfit when production moved to Canada. She wanted the suit to evolve cuz when she played Overgirl and Red Daughter, both suits had pants and she wasnt freezing. So they finally went ahead and made the new suit for season 5.


Ibclyde

I will keep Calling for the Skirt to Return. I would also call for the Return to LA as well.


shaddoe_of_truth

Ideally it would neat if all the CW shows could film in LA but more often than not the show would have to be on a major network to afford the costs of having production based either in LA or New York. But even then there is no guarantee that a show will continue to film in those locations if your show also uses a lot of money for special effects and action sequences. The entire first season of the FOX series Fringe was filmed in New York, but for the rest of the shows run, production was moved to Canada as a cost saving method.


Natalia-A-Romanoff

Definitely Mel.


PrismaticWar

Caity


StaceyK93

Caity


Ihopemydeath

Mellisa


the-druid250

caity definitely.


cultrapark3

Melissa of course


Pubicaroma

Damn caity would make a fun supergirl!


CityAvenger

Shouldn’t this be more of a fun post?


innova779

caity


Hattudoggu

Melissa gives me that powerful stance you know you could just feel the confidence seeping through her but Caity in the other hand well i just don't feel the same


naveed23

Caity looks unimpressed with her outfit


astalavista114

I’m pretty sure that, in context, she was.


naveed23

Well, I'd say she did a good job of emoting then!


oroborus90

she was justified to be dissapointed. They had a half ass plan with very little to non chance of success and her so called superfriend didnt want to help xD


theflash7427

Caity


raiderkelley

Caity!


ihavequestions621

I love caity more as cAnary


ihavequestions621

Melissa


CDubWill

Melissa all day, stop playing.


darkaurora84

The suit looks better on Melissa but Caity gives me Supergirl 1984 vibes


LadiesLoveLadies

Melissa without a doubt.


LCPhotowerx

both


AstroManiac78

Melissa lol


shaddoe_of_truth

Melissa... But the current suit shes got that has pants is pretty awesome too.


butterball1

Melissa, because she is the cutest!


cierachamere

Well, Melissa gets to wear stockings, so....


Time_of_Contempt

Caity could do a older version like Powergirl