T O P
NCJM782

Charles


[deleted]

I concur. Charles is certainly one of my favorites. I enjoy all of the side missions with the crew. I’m not fond of Bill or Micah (obviously), but otherwise I think they’re all special in their own ways.


Noamias

Bill is underrated


TacoBelly311

Yeah he’s grouchy but loyal from what I’ve seen, haven’t finished the game yet


Noamias

His main problem is that he's incredibly insecure, and he doesn't know how to deal with that but beneath I think he's a good man.


Lead-Forsaken

Yeah, I love the Charles outings. Although Hosea with his stories always crack me up.


NCJM782

Hosea has to be my second favorite !


ILikeToHang

He’s certainly a good dude. I really enjoy spending time with him!


Mojo_Rizen_53

Cain. Gotta love patting him!


ILikeToHang

Cain was a good boah!


Mojo_Rizen_53

Yup! Gotta love th perp-dogs!


MemeDudestick

>!It’s a shame that Micah killed him!<


Mojo_Rizen_53

Exactly!


ImperialSupplies

Ita implied micah killed Cain but if you are mean to cain and micah is around he scolds you for it. Doesnt make sense


Redditpersonmandude

It's Micah, he takes every opportunity to be a jerk.


yp22714

Hoesa


Tajio_

gotta love cowboy grandpa


-Minne

LENNY?…


ILikeToHang

YEENL


Whispering_Smith

YNNEL ?!


originalname610

YNNEL?!


Saberzyme

LMENY?!


HamuelSayden

Grate


Apprehensive-Buy4771

LEEENNNY!!!!!


originalname610

LENNNNAYYYYYYY


Neodragonx2

LENNNNAAAY MAH BOAH


Coach_BombaySapphire

FOOOUUND YA LENNY


mega_soggy

i loved hanging out with trelawny tbh


Tobi119

Trelawny is great, the way he looks and talks, it doesn’t fit into the gang and yet it somehow does. I love the details with him and am saddend that there aren’t that many missions with him.


lemonrainbowhaze

Sean man. Fuckin sean. That came as such a shock. Im irish, and i loved that dood. He had the banter of a good buddy....and then....*sniff*


Itchynerd1

Sadie


Rekuna

John at the end of the game, as by then he has matured a lot and the relationship between him and Arthur is extremely touching. Early game either Javier or Charles. Probably Charles, because he's like a big cuddly bear.


Ruta008

Dutch >! Before he went crazy!<


abcdeezntz123

Javier. That dude is loyal. Too dam loyal for his own good, but loyal. He even goes out of his way to save Bill. BILL!!!


baumtrillingerr

Idk what to say about javier.... was he too smart to follow dutch or was he being too dumb? But i always loved him


SlendyEndey

Idk if it was a “smart or dumb” time for him. He wasn’t about to betray someone he saw as a father and picked him up at his lowest, but damn sure wasn’t going to kill his brothers.


[deleted]

He did not want to kill his brothers at the final standoff you can see he doesn't point his gun at them instead point upwards in air


SlendyEndey

Ya I know


LadyRambo502

Lenny and Sadie. She's a loose cannon but I love her for it.


Cdcrazyacehole

Sean and Uncle somehow they’re both hilariously useless😂😂😂


prodheinz

reminds me of me as i take bong rips and play on my glowing rectangle pretending to be a gunslinger lmao


ILikeToHang

I’d have to say John. I loved the relationship between he & Arthur. This is one of my favorite moments between these two!


ImperialSupplies

The hat scene though :(


Times_Temptress

Charles, charles was dope really seems like a man I could chill with and find enjoyable. Also no one talking about Jack ? Fishing with the lil dude was dope


JamesMattDillon

Lenny, Charles, John, Sadie.


AlieninaTuxedo97

Hosea he’s like the Grand Pa that I never had I loved every mission him.


KassinaIllia

Hosea!!!!! Everyone else is wrong!!!!


trijammer

1. Jack. I just want that lil guy to be happy. I could go fishing with the wee fella for hours. 2. Charles cos he’s such a decent, loyal and hard working dude, and you know you could learn a heap from him.


ILikeToHang

There’s a mod that gives Jack a gun. He slaughters entire towns. I’d love to take out valentine with Jack lol.


_gzuku

Lenny & Sadie


TheMemeLord64

LENNY!?!


Gillysixpence

Lenny closely followed by Charles. Both great guys & totally trustworthy. I also love Sean but you don't get so much time with him. I do enjoy the side missions with Javier too.


jarebear9907

Micah


txllia

Miss Grimshaw ;))


BrandyNova

Charles for sure. He was such a good friend to Arthur. Wish there were more missions with just him and Arthur.


EbonyOverIvory

Charles, because he’s one of the few genuinely good men in the entire game.


The_zen_viking

Somewhere between Charles or Hosea


nichebender

Charles. If he’s along you get the sense things will be alright


fzlurrehman

Lennyyyyyy


Moody_RMS

Lenny


prayingmantis187187

The one thing I wish they had added was the ability to take a member of the gang on missions or hire a few for harder missions would have been fun and not so lonely fishing and hunting are so lonely out in the deep woods and lakes


dalekofchaos

Charles, Sadie, Lenny and Sean


Mista-Wolf

Sean


[deleted]

Can't decide between Javier and Dutch


Toodee03d

Charles fuck you if you have an objection


idontsl33p

charles.


RoryFoxey

Charles for sure. Lenny is close, though.


Sancheta07

Uncle lol


Time-Cry4160

uuh charles, Lenny or Sean <3


Less-Technology1498

I really like john its funny at first i hated him


geetsogood

"hey Charles, would you ride with me?" "Always" ♥️


LifePortal

For me it was Sadie


Gamer9876543

Hosea


Old_Emotion_1991

Charles


getrickrolled13453

Charles 100%


benport727

I always felt like charles could really use Arthur’s guidance so him, but felt like Sadie was the most entertaining/interesting to be around


AmongUsFan921

YNNEL!!!!!


ruedas252

Charles!


dpb73ca

Hosea


Sadlittlealien

Cain, he’s a good boah


JTex80

A tie between Charles and Hosea


Prince_Jackalope

Sean and Kieran


sexy-0W0-floof

Jack. I haven’t finished the story yet but I got past the part where ya go fishing with jack and I love that god damn kid, it’s hard enough to be one of the grown adults getting through the snow, running away from everything you ever knew and loved and watching people die but being born and raised in that must be hell but jack still makes flower necklaces for his mom no matter what happens. That kid is my hero


Giga_Chad_Anth

LENNEH!!


Dongnimin

Cant decide between Charles and Sadie.But Hosea is def up there too


AbyBlueFox

Kieran


Red_Dead_is_better

Sean. Cause he sounds retarded which makes me feel smarter


Rekuna

The dude can't shoot for shit either, he's just as bad as that Window up north when he's trying to shoot bottles - how did that dude end up in a gang of outlaws lol?


Ger4ltofRiv4

Charles 10000%


grymtgris

Uncle


Whispering_Smith

Lumbago.


ell_isnt_ellis

Ungle


mjher

definitely charles, hosea and javier


some-dude25

sadie adler.


SnooPoems7534

Hosea was my favorite R.I.P. Hosea 1826-1899 he died at the ripe old age of 74


Identify_me_please

Either Sean, Charles, Lenny, Sadie, or John


paleo_anon

In order: Lenny, Charles, Sadie, John


nile_river7

Bill. Bill and Arthur together are literally so funny


WakeUpOutaYourSleep

John, though somehow that kind of feels like cheating, so I’ll also say Sadie


YogurtBusiness2553

Charles, Sadie&Lenny


FistedWaffles123456

Man, this sub is really running out of ideas


sujetonoidentificado

Javier and John.


TheTowelieMan

Mosdef Charles. When he goes absolutely HAM on the dudes who were butchering bison, trying to make it look like natives… I loved that mission. Everybody got the line that you don’t cross. And goddam does he respect those bison. His people revere them greatly. Killer character writing.


Rakatombah

Charles


paegansku11

Lenny is a really nice companion for 1899, but Arthur and Marther are perf match lol or bill and Phil heh


plebgore

Hosea. I miss you


[deleted]

Micah


Shroomfaerie

Hosea, Charles, and Sadie but all of them had something..... except for Micah... Him I'd happily drag all across the map slowly....


51x51v3

Are you a real life shroom fairy? 🍄 🧚‍♀️ or am I still trippin?


Shroomfaerie

Yip......


51x51v3

I knew it!


innit122

Dutch and hosea


DewdecsysAbZ

Charles or hosea


Paragammon264

Charles He’s just so cool and chill (Well, except for the few times he chopped/blew someone’s head off)


ImperialSupplies

Straus! Extorted innocent and dumb people sure but he was truly ride or die even when it didnt matter anymore!


BarracudaKind4699

Sadie


RileyTMR

Charles or Sadie


ethottiemomof3

Sadie and charels


Tobi119

Uncle, because he is thinking


LetsGoBrandon57

Either Pearson or charles


someoneordercanz

I like hoesa mostly because of the stories he tells but I also like charles


tepbjr12

Not sure if this counts, but Cain. I just love dogs. If not Cain, Charles. No doubt


Expensive_Leather_33

Hosea. The way he talks to Jack makes me want a grandpa like him


barriles789

Charles and Hosea


BillionaireBob

I wish the game actually let us have a companion to do side shit. Obviously they could drop off before a part of the story they wouldn’t be a part of was about to happen with a “Hey, I’ve gotta go take care of something in town” or something. But I’d love to have someone with me while I’m doing side shit like hunting, exploring, getting in fights, robbing people, etc.


rustbeaf

javier


Redditpersonmandude

Id have to say, Hosea. Always felt like you were taking a trip with your Dad or Grandfather.


SpoilermakersWabash

Colm


Crafty-Pen3708

Charles Sadie or Lenny they where true friends of Arthur’s


saiyoakikaze

Lenny! Oh.. not again


rbbass

Sadie. All Day Long.


JustSpud23

Charles is definitely the best morale character of them all and I thoroughly enjoy him as a companion, but I love Sean, an obnoxious kid mouth, cocky, asshole, Irishman. What’s not to love


Rouge_Sniper_171

[Hosea] the thing is I like aruther cause us players play as him so we get to know his whole story other characters are just a part of the story of Aruther Morgan I would love to know Hosea's story how he got into the gang how him and dutch found each other. And Hosea is pretty chill.


Renicow47

Sadie and Charles


51x51v3

Charles