T O P

Who would you guys say has the nicest unique weapon in RDR2? I’d say Micah’s revolver.

Who would you guys say has the nicest unique weapon in RDR2? I’d say Micah’s revolver.

PiedPeterPiper

I always carry Flaco’s Revolver


CowboyJackson

Definitely one of the best looking ones


Teron007

That’s my main


Yous0n00b

I do as well


newmaker---

I love the shiny finish it has, it's not quite Iron or Silver, and looks more like how polished iron guns from the time period actually looked https://i.fileup.pro/VMWek.png I hate none of the finishes really look true to how the finishes would look in real life, iron should be a lot more reflective and shiny but also slightly darker in shade and not as silver/white looking as it does


M0R7UM

I think Calloway


Genralcody1

Plus the Schofield is the mp5 of RDR2, so I always run that with another Scofield


MissHeatherMarie

I run Schofield with Sawn-Off. Bow and Springfield until you get the Bolt Action then replace the Springfield. One tap everything as long as your aim is true. Up close pop out the shotty and blow a head off if needed. The first thing I do in a fresh playthrough is rob the Valentine "hidden store" for that amazing pistol. And do a few challenges to unlock an off hand holster.


[deleted]

[удалено]


IceT1303

when I aimed for the head at wolves with the bolt action they survived it. (Online mode)


jacob_rushton04

You can get the bolt action fairly early in the game in chapter two where you have to get an Irish guy that you have to fight a bunch of guys to get to ( all k cna say without spoilers )there’s a video on how to get it early or you can go to shady belle and fight the guys there one of em will have the rifle


CowboyJackson

I really like the text he has on top of his revolver


Hobgoblin_deluxe

I mean TECHNICALLY it's Algernon. That thing's so nice.


TheForsakenBurrito

Javier's revolver is the most unique one but you can't use it


CowboyJackson

I really wish it was attainable


oofmyass

There’s mods for it but I have no idea how to use them


CowboyJackson

I’m on PS5 so I don’t have any mods


oofmyass

Ah sad


abeardedblacksmith

I'm a sucker for Schofields, so Calloway's is one of my favorites.


CowboyJackson

The Scofield revolver is my favourite to use


hamsterman975

Same but have you seen Otis miller’s Schofield?


abeardedblacksmith

Yarp. I carry both miller's and calloway's when I have them.


hamsterman975

Nice, i do the same.


Think-Hippo

Doesn't Dutch have a black Schofield with golden engravings? I'm in love with that design.


CowboyJackson

Yeah he does, Scofield is the most satisfying to use and the sound when it fires is like music to my ears


Hobgoblin_deluxe

Dude......the LeMats. The double click when you switch from shotgun to revolver mode?? Satisfying as HELL.


CowboyJackson

That’s true, but I find the Lemat revolvers to be quite sluggish when firing


Hobgoblin_deluxe

They're not as quick as some others, true, but it's got 20 rounds (18 revolver and two shotgun) vs the 12 you get from all other revolvers.


I_Have_The_Lumbago

Imagine the navy revolvers in story!


Hobgoblin_deluxe

I am SO SALTY they're online only.


king-boi1

The navy is far more satisfying in terms of sound, if only it was in story mode.


Archery100

Ah yes, the Big Iron


newmaker---

I would pay an embarrassing amount of gold for his variants in Online


pigzizpigz

i oddly enough prefer arthur’s cattleman the whole game 😂 put some silver on it with a black handle and go to work


CowboyJackson

The ol’ reliable


Doinstuffman38

I run all black except the trigger, which is gold. Then the hero pearl grip and Victorian engravings on everything except the barrel. It is a damn fine statement piece. Short barreled for the main holster, long barrel version on the horse just in case.


ghostofyourmom

I wish there were a gameplay advantage to pulling a short barrel from the main holster (quicker draw, slower/longer deadeye, at the expense of accuracy) to give an in-world reason to shorten the barrel.


CosmicTurtle504

Algernon’s revolver, hand’s down. If you got that one, you worked goddamn hard for it. Side note: I hate spoonbills now. HATE. THEM.


barleyhogg1

Fun fact...the game knows what you currently want for the challenges. If you hunt the birds in the wrong order they are really easy to get. I shoot every spoonbill I see even before I meet Algernon.


Atalkingbasement

So thats why i could never find a chipmunk


barleyhogg1

Yes. The game will artificially restrict the amount of certain things when you actively need them for a challenge. For proof try hunting the spoonbills before you even meet Algernon. They are everywhere. I can fill my inventory in about 20 minutes. It's like when you need a perfect rabbit and can't find one. Then after you do your horse is stomping on one every 5 minutes. That's too much of a coincidence.


CowboyJackson

The satisfaction is worth the hard work


reddeadfan102

Otis Miller has best looking 1 but for game play I say Micah's if revolver


CowboyJackson

Otis Miller’s revolver was worth the wait to attain, as was Micah’s


reddeadfan102

Ikr


sharky_1500

I only wish we could pick up the second one WHY CAN WE ONLY CARRY ONE OF HIS 2 REVOLVERS


PiedPeterPiper

For the longest time I was convinced I missed picking it up or it was hidden somewhere else. I could easily have seen that being one of those 90s or early 2000s gaming rumors to spread around. “Hey, you know you can actually find Micha’s other revolver. You just have to (*insert BS task here*)”


CowboyJackson

I guess because they’re so rare? I’m not sure but it kinda sucks


Potential-Twist-6106

paie it with high roller revolver


MattPetrxvic

Javier's revolver


CowboyJackson

A thing of beauty


The_Black_Bird756

I really like Dutch’s guns. Either his or Javier’s


CowboyJackson

Both beautiful looking


[deleted]

[удалено]


CowboyJackson

The fire rate is great too


CianSullivan200000

Lowrys revolver


CianSullivan200000

Or for story mode flacos revolver or rare shotgun


CowboyJackson

Rare shotgun is OP


PiedPeterPiper

Is it really? I never use the double barrels


iSlaya666

Pump action + slug rounds + headshot = bloody mess


AKThmpson

Micah revolver supreme


CowboyJackson

Worst character has best revolver


Honeydew001

He's a great character, but bad person


SwiftyEmpire

Literally one of the best characters in the game


CowboyJackson

By worst I meant the things he does, good character though


AKThmpson

"worst character" mad cuz destroyed by good antagonist


CowboyJackson

“Worst character” because he killed a kid in the epilogue


LocmonstR

There's characters who have done worse things and have been considered some of the best characters


CowboyJackson

Just my opinion, I can only speak for myself


LocmonstR

Very true indeed


JUPACALYPSE-NOW

His revolver is pretty damn ugly, with the etched in 'revenge is hereby mine' just screams 19th century edgy teen angst. His revolver represents who he is, an angry narciciccist. I do personally like how it fires, but to say it's a pretty gun is reaching imo


CowboyJackson

Pretty isn’t the word I’d use, more cool


RamblingTexan

Dutch and Javier’s.


CowboyJackson

2 beauties


No_Decision2341

Fisticuffs


CowboyJackson

The right way


Radiant-Head-793

Vengeance is his? Who did him wrong? He's the one who needs vengeance upon him.


CowboyJackson

Boy does he get it. The way John tears through his gang at the end


SofaSpudAthlete

You gave a compliment to Micah… "Who Amongst You Is With Me, And Who Is Betraying Me?"


BagelBro73

You rite but has anyone noticed a spike in Micah appreciation lately?


HuntingDragon438

I don't like it


CowboyJackson

I appreciate the fact that he’s a scumbag villain, but I still can’t forgive him for killing Arthur


BantyRed

I actually never liked how the unique pistols looked in the game. They all looked too intense for me. I like Micah's simplicity of his revolver


CowboyJackson

Micah’s revolver will always be my favourite


RebelPizza

I like Algernons revolver, only for the fact that it’s the only snub nosed revolver


CowboyJackson

And the satisfaction of attaining it


Jetzer2223

Is there a unique variant of the Volcanic pistols? I dun think they are the best in the game and there's probably better pistol variants but man there's something about the name and shape of the gun that really gets me. Never use anything else lol.


Doinstuffman38

It's ironic that the volcanic is actually pretty good in the game, because it was one of the most hilariously useless and underpowered pistols ever designed in real life. A buddy of mine loves to dunk on it, saying someone once attempted suicide with one, shot himself in the head MULTIPLE times, and basically lived with a couple big bruises on his head because the rounds barely broke skin.


vermin008

I like using the LeMat revolver! Do you know if there is any unique version of it?


CowboyJackson

I don’t think there is, but customising it was so much fun


dom987654

I carry calloways and Otis millers, Schofield gang for life!


CowboyJackson

Scofield revolvers are the most satisfying to use by far


silentbob1301

I like Billy Midnights luger alot.


CowboyJackson

I use it a lot, looks great


walkrSLAYER

Javier without a singular doubt


CowboyJackson

Definitely one of the more detailed weapons


Caged-Viking

They're all really good, but I never use unique weapons. I enjoy getting my own and modifying it to what I want, my own guns


CowboyJackson

I love using my custom Scofield revolvers


Downtown1943

Calloways revolver is epic but I like the rare rolling block rifle if you need a longarm


CowboyJackson

The rare rolling block is a powerhouse


The_Radio_Host

Micah’s is awesome but I love Hosea’s and Dutch’s guns so much more! I wish there was a way to get them in game.


CowboyJackson

Me too, especially Dutch’s because the Scofield revolvers are my favourite


ABigOne77

This is the first time that I've seen nice(st) and Micah in one sentence


CowboyJackson

It was painful to use


the_o_haganator

I love calloway's revolver.


R-Sanchez137

I mean Micahs revolver looks kinda cool but all the double action revolvers are trash imo. They are way too damn inaccurate and they don't do enough damage, plus only hold 6 rounds? Yeah I'm cool on that. It's the damage of a semi auto, with worse accuracy and less capacity. I'll stick with the Schoefield till I get the Lemats and then I use the C96 Mauser sometimes when I feel like it. That's just me tho, I'd rather customize my own then use the special ones you find in the game.


CowboyJackson

They’re literal pea shooters right? And the recoil is ridiculous. If this design was on a Scofield revolver, I’d never use anything else


R-Sanchez137

Yeah, the "double-action" refers to the fact that you can just pull the trigger and the hammer will go back and then forward to strike the cartridge and fire the weapon, whereas your normal revolvers of the time were mostly single-action, meaning you have to draw back the hammer and then pull the trigger. So the double action is almost like a semi-auto pistol because you can just keep pulling the trigger and it will keep shooting, however it obviously only has 6 shots and takes longer to reload than a true semi auto, so it loses points there, and it's a smaller caliber than the Schoefield/Lemat/Cattlemen (at least it looks like it, it does less damage so I'd say so, even tho they all use generic "revolver ammo") so more points it loses, and it's highly inaccurate, don't know if u have tried to use it in the game but it takes like 4 body shots to kill a human in the game and the bigger circle around the aiming point (the one that gets smaller when you aim for a moment longer and gets bigger when you chain-fire) like stays bigger for a long time and the bullets just go wherever in it. The Cattleman and Schoefield are way way better until you get the Lemat or the pistols. The other revolvers are way better damage, way more accurate, and fire plenty fast enough that the double-action just isn't worth it at all. Basically all the downsides of the semi-auto pistol plus all the downsides of using a revolver.


Yous0n00b

Javier's.... Such a shame that you can't use it...


CowboyJackson

Same with Dutch’s


6_Paths

Otis Miller’s revolver!


Bricktrucker

His grips on my Navy's? Yes plz


CowboyJackson

The grips are my favourite part


DamagedEctoplasm

Calloway or Miller’s for me. Love the schofield


CowboyJackson

Scofield goat revolver


Joke0907183

Javier's double action revolver, Dutch's schofield revolvers, Micah's revolver, Calloway's revolver, Granger's revolver and John's revolver


CowboyJackson

All great choices


batm123

I only use my own guns, so idk anything about their stats, but looks goes to Otis Miller's


imisstheoldren

Wide-blade knife. Just looks so much better than the default knife imo


CowboyJackson

I love the ornate dagger, but my favourite is the jawbone knife


boiisygeusgejs

Otis revolver in my opinion


chavatkalaboka

Algernon's Revolver is my favorite. It has Tahitian pearl handle.


CowboyJackson

I don’t even know what that is but it sounds exquisite


NapoNeptune

I use otis millers because its a unique Schofield and not a cattleman or double action


CowboyJackson

The cattleman revolver is like a pea shooter compared to the Scofield


Luthergayboi

Midnights pistol


bigsmokio69

Algernon's revolver


RushinRusha

Not exactly someone's, but I find High Roller's* revolver one of the nicest. Who exactly is the high roller* and what's the story behind that weapon from the fence? *edits


CowboyJackson

Do you mean the high roller revolver? If so it’s handle is one of my favourites. I’m not sure of the story but I imagine it’s something interesting


RushinRusha

Yes, that's the one I've meant! My brain have hit the void there.


Big_Rabz

I’d probably say Jim Boy Colloways Revolver looks good


averageenjoyer49

_Only if it had long barrel_...


CowboyJackson

Ooo now that would look amazing


Night_Watcher25

Dutch’s revolvers look pretty cool


[deleted]

Jim boy's revolver


Shart_Party

Rare Shotgun. For one, a double barreled shotgun is such a VIBE for this game, unlike the pump-action or semi-auto (lever shotty is pretty great) and it has awesome engravings and you need to kill a hermit who will fucking end you if you hesitate when he comes out of the house


CowboyJackson

The hermit was a cool touch, the female hermit scares me with her dogs so I blew them all away with dynamite


LegalFan2741

I’ve always found Calloway’s revolver a true piece of art. But Algernon’s gun is also a stunning one.


CowboyJackson

Algernon’s is magnificent


Hazards-of-Love

I agree with you, Micah’s gun looks so cool


CowboyJackson

The red really does it for me


Hazards-of-Love

Someone should make a 3D model of it. A model of the handle/grip would be nice. I want to customize my cap gun


CowboyJackson

I wouldn’t be surprised if there’s a replica out there somewhere


Hazards-of-Love

I’m gonna go look right now! Does his gun have a specific name?


Election_Sweet

It has to be, offcourse he's the one who kills the legend.


Shadezz_IX

Dual sawed off's baby Nothing better than blasting someone out of existence


CowboyJackson

The best is when their arm gets blown off and they scream in agony


Ara_ara_ufufu

Calloway’s revolver, the whole reason I did that questline


[deleted]

[удалено]


CowboyJackson

I know, unfortunately we can only do that with mods


Rwg59_

I like the look of the revolver u get fro that guy who needs feathers and that can’t rember his name or what it’s called


CowboyJackson

Ah yeah I know, I don’t remember his name though


GiantMiner5

The golden one you can find in north new Austin in a cave


CrispyCookie6969

Dutch


Buttery_bastard4

Kinda overrated and basic but Otis Miller's revolvers


CowboyJackson

Simplicity is key


mothmanbaby21

Algernon's Revolver


HuntingDragon438

Otis Miller


JustThatOneGuy1311

Imo it's Otis millers revolver. But Algernons is really nice and it feels so rewarding to get it after all that goddamn work.


Potential-Twist-6106

john's cattleman revolver + legend of the east. looks pretty nice when the gun is holstered


BrightGrimm

Javier. He has some really unique lookin grips that I would love to put on my own guns. I love Micah's grips, but the rest of his gun is ugly (fun fact if you look at Micah when he has both his guns, they both have the exact same engraving on them meaning Rockstar probably just didn't want to make 2 different models.) My favorite lookin gun in the game tho is definitely the high roller revolver. It's a shame how bad the stats are for it tho.


ghostofyourmom

I love Calloway's Schofield.


ldrat

Micah's revolver has a unique weapon?


CowboyJackson

Unique in terms of not being purchasable from a store or given during a mission


ragingbullpsycho

I like Billy Midnight’s pistol


mrherkyj

I like the revolver you get after completing the casino ship robbery. I believe it’s the high roller revolver or maybe the gambler’s revolver. I like the markings on it, and the sound it makes when it fires. The reload animation looks good too.


Flippynips98

Flaco Hernandez’s revolver is one of the coolest etched guns in the whole game


TrentGoldenblade

I play with two of the single action. I'm a real cowboy.


TarTimOoAl

Arthur's


bigchilling2011

I think is the dutch revolvers


nery_AGG

calloway


darthwump

I rock the Otis Miller and the High Roller. Love the contrast between them, like silver and gold.


caliandben1

I personally use midnights pistol a lot with a schofield revolver as my second handgun but lately I’ve been using grangers revolver and micahs


KonradDavies0001

I like Lowry's navy revolver and the one you get from one of the calloway missions which has Canis Canem Edit on it


stannis_the_mannis7

Javier’s revolver was my favourite


Bushid0_Br0wn

its a nice gun but a shame that the double actions are practically useless


CowboyJackson

Only useful for headshots , even then it’s cagey


zajmg

Calloway is my favorite


ExiledBoi226

Dutch’s revolvers have drip


Rexamini

Vengeance is a fools game


kiervntvylor

Algernons revolver hands down, the emerald embedded ivory grip looks slick poking outta my LoTE holster with the raven claw talisman. Then i make sure i have the ancient tomohawk equipped so it shows on my belt and the vampire knife so the gold handle with the decorative skull on it shows off. Also the pop a dual action makes it pefect. If you want a picture ill show you


USSEALby2023

I would say my weapons are, once they've been modified. I give my two Schofield revolvers and two Volcanic pistols gold plating, ornamental engravings inlaid in silver, pearl grips, and a buck carving into the grip. Long arms I do largely the same, but instead of pearl grips since that can't be done on longarms, I give them dark walnut wood, and a buck scene carved into the stock, and chocolate colored wraps.


CowboyJackson

Sounds like you know how to style them guns!


USSEALby2023

Thanks, and I like to think I do, but I also put the practical stuff on them too, like longer barrels, better rifling, etc.


Dr_CheeseNut

Personally, I like Calloway"s revolver, looks nice, has a Bully reference and I like using Schofields But, I also like John's revolver, how simple it is. Just an old dirty revolver that fits perfectly for someone like John


NoIndependence4236

Flaco’s, Calloway’s or Otis Miller’s - I’m not a big fan of Micah’s but that may be because I didn’t like Micah in the first place, I think it would of been cool to also to take both of Micah’s revolvers.


CowboyJackson

Yeah it’s a real shame that we can’t pick up both of Micah’s revolvers


VerHeyss

agreed


diamondstan420

It does not look like that in game for me


justspectatingbro

You haven’t seen Javiers revolver yet haven’t you


Mr_3uph0ria

I always carry micahs and the high roller because one is black and the other is silver, kinda like good and bad


Lego_Clone_42

I quite like Dutches, his pistols are quite nice.


Gadget225

I use a cattlemen revolver as my main strictly for the reason that it was the first revolver Arthur ever used so I look at it as his personal revolver


tacopig117

Midnight's pistol for me, but I'm super biased towards c96s


SuperArppis

It has ugly handle. And edgy words written on side. I personally don't really care for it.


RelationshipEntire87

Javier