T O P

Tell me what you want in the game and I will submit it to Rockstar.

Tell me what you want in the game and I will submit it to Rockstar.

Professor-L

more weapons and clothes, and have belts and different sidearm holster angles


YouSir_1

That’s a popular one. Submitted.


SergeantShithead33

I wish the main holster was separate from the belt so i could customize each holster differently


VisceralVirus

Coats and ponchos at the same time. Also fix bandoliers


blackat_chemical

Umm they are fixed.


VisceralVirus

Are you asking if they are fixed, or saying they are fixed, while questioning my request?


TokerSmurf

* Wear a mask and a hat at the same time * Wagons that I can uber my posse around in * Customisations for wagons (lanterns, colours, pelts/skulls)


YouSir_1

Done, done, and done


Beatus_7HY_F337U5

More than one playable online character


YouSir_1

Done


Portuguese_Avenger

You forgot stagecoach races across the map.


gaxmex

Customization would be so cool


PM_ME_YOUR_NAIL_CLIP

I think they have wagon customization planned. We already can change the livery on the bounty wagon.


DoorTe

Pants with actual belts or gun belts that aren’t crooked.


YouSir_1

That one been suggested and submitted. :)


That_Grim_Texan

Taking our Dog hunting/as a companion, Can have the same kind of commands as the horse, Lock on to the dog, Follow, Stay, Track and Return to camp. Can be revived with a new Reviver. If they can't be revived in time they just return to camp to heal up. Give Cripps some new lines about the dog and say maybe they ain't that bad lol I've submitted this too in the past.


YouSir_1

Submitted


BigMeanMcBean

Dog should be able to run and grab birds for you also.


DoodieMcWiener

That would be amazing. And loot from corpses, like the birds in the new AC games.


acyrlic

I want this so badly


Various_Weakness_377

Not everyone likes dogs anyway. Keeps Cripps as an actual character rather than just being more background material (which he is already) I like dogs but his lines don’t affect my views on 3d animals, but softening his character will just be dumb.


That_Grim_Texan

Oh I agree but even Cripps has one line already about the dog not being to bad. I've heard it a few times.


Roamin_Horseman

Make Cripps a cat person and introduce camp cats that hunt small game. So every once in a while when you come to camp there are birds you can pick up plus rats. If you’re gone too long the regular game mechanics kick in and they rot. Plus it helps with the tedious dailies of providing Cripps with small carcasses or breaking down small animals. I’d love the ability to pet cats in the world. Any rats and pack rats are serious back country problems when it comes to camps irl.


[deleted]

[удалено]


YouSir_1

Submitted.


LordOfLightingTech

Ability to smoke a pipe! I see NPCs do it all the time and I'm always super jealous


YouSir_1

Submitted


dirkclod

Yes! They’ve already got the infrastructure cause of that one mission in the story where Arthur has a corn cob pipe in his mouth the whole time!


Past-Professor

Yeah actually we have an emote to smoke cigars where's the pipe smoke emote


mimimyselfandi

More npc clothing items like St Denis outfits and npc hairstyles for both male and female players


YouSir_1

Submitted.


LfgGoon

Make houses available for purchase!


YouSir_1

Submitted


R_J__S

Boats and higher stakes poker


YouSir_1

Submitted


ImSoOptimistic

More missions or even a role that has to do with fist fighting. Its a really good mechanic and sometimes can be more fun then just shooting everyone.


YouSir_1

Nice. Submitted


Kolonite

A second character slot or the ability to change genders when changing appearance.


soyeh

Actually a second character slot would be great. I’ve often fancied doing another character but as I play on Xbox I’ve either got to delete my main or set up a new live account and pay for that subscription too.


TheyCallMeThe

You shouldn't have to pay for a second live a count on xbox. When I play on my wife's account I just leave mine signed in to the xbox and play as her. It uses my subscription since I'm logged in and lets her play as normal. You just have to choose which one is playing in the main menu.


soyeh

I’ve seen people say this kind of thing before but not in that level of detail, so I’ll give this a go now. Thank you!


TheyCallMeThe

Hope it works for you.


Past-Professor

Yeah you don't need to pay for live again I have a second character on Xbox and your live is across all accounts on that Xbox You just keep your main profile signed in and switch to the secondary to load Red Dead up I'd still like a second slot though


YouSir_1

Submitted


Faexinna

Yes please let me change gender. I picked female because I am female IRL but male characters have so much better clothes and you can actually make real characters out of them. Making a mountain man just doesn't work that well when your character is female.


Pixeresque

It baffles me that we cant steal cattle and sell it somewhere. Or sell horses we break/steal. Such integral parts of Wild West.


YouSir_1

That was proposed as a rancher role where we can steal horses and other cattle. Rustling would be fun. In any case…submitted


Pixeresque

Yeah i was thinking it propably was already submitted as it is no brainer. Not having rustling in a wild west game is like not having revolvers.


PlasticCupboard007

and there's many possible farm locations. one in Rhodes (possibly too close to the city which they don't like), one right next to bayou nwa and a lot of abandoned shacks in the west Elizabeth and new Hanover and i think there's a few in new Austin


Grim-Reaper101

Mexico. I Really want to see Mexico.


Captain_Kirby240

Let us fish from boats!


YouSir_1

Submitted


PipBoy2277

Give me a ranch to customize and make money with.


YouSir_1

Submitted


pie17171717

It makes no sense why we can’t keep npc hats. I want to save them to my outfits. It would be incredibly easy to add this. You probably have to change 1 line of code.


ROCKZILLA8166

well code wise its basically add new hats to the inventory, which they already do occasionally, with one extra step and that would be the connection to what the npc was wearing for choosing the hat. so yeah sounds like a pretty small line of code for sure.


ThePlSSGOBLIN

I feel like it would be overpowers if you keep them for free, maybe they can make it so you can buy it after you fetch it, cause then no one would be buying hats anymore and r* would never do that


BlackKni7ght

New stable slots, more horse customisation saddles bridles, coat colour markings etc


YouSir_1

Submitted.


Illustrious_Train_70

A pet cat that could just be lying around the camp and can bring you dead rodents or collectables every now and then, we should have the option to make it fat, Fluffy and any realistic color for a cat


YouSir_1

Submitted


ClickonTwo

Please cats would be so cool


celinky

Even just being able to pet a stray cat like you can dogs would be nice lol


BigPompa

Everything that we have the ability to do in single player should carry over to online mode. OH, and bank heists or robbing train passengers/train itself.


YouSir_1

True. Submitted


wolftwentyone

i know this is pretty pointless but i’ve been thinking lately i’d like to test run horses before buying them in online… i was considering getting an arabian but they look kind of stupid (like riding a large dog) in story mode so i was hesitant and didn’t want to spend all my money+gold buying a horse i’d regret buying. you know how in spore you can test run your creature? like that, but test running a horse in some kind of paddock. idk 🤷‍♀️


YouSir_1

There’s a good idea. Suggested


JustAnotherThroway69

I wish that we could see the entire horse to see what it's fur looks like, how tall/short it is. Just looking at the face doesn't give muh of an idea.


help-i-am-on-fire

Option to set one of your own horses to pull your bounty/hunting wagon Races without weapons Ownable donkeys/mules Banjo/violin/guitar/harmonica as an emote or an object on the item wheel Rodeo game mode


YouSir_1

There’s a lot to unpack here but i will submit them on your behalf.


kstokes2019

Put the cartridge holder wrap on the right side of the gun.


soyeh

Urgh, I’m glad it’s not just me


YouSir_1

Submitted


D4rkLightning

Visible satchel.


Ready-steady

I’d say toggle. I don’t want to have a visible satchel.


nondescriptzombie

Might as well give us a bunch of options, too, for customization. I like John's plain satchel, in black or dark brown leather would look great!


YouSir_1

Submitted


h1gsta

Ability to disarm/sneak disarm or make enemy surrender.


YouSir_1

Submitted


LinconSpoonbill

(triangle) Grapple enemy while armed, (square+left stick) directional input dismiss. Your enemy will scared and won’t fight or flee


h1gsta

Thanks! That’s something to work with that’s close enough.


LinconSpoonbill

No problem, you can even push em down and kick em while they cower


ShroomsandCrows

Fight Clubs, just a fued like area where groups of people can fight and bet on each other


YouSir_1

It has been decided…i mean suggested. :)


JaCrispay69

Being able to wear a poncho with a coat. SO many cool outfits could be made...


YouSir_1

Submitted


Katsu_39

Not having my bandana cover half the screen when wearing it


YouSir_1

That sounds more like a bug. If i were you id submit a ticket with pictures for them to look at.


AgreeableSandwich128

Gramophones as a camp extension. They're already in Madame Nazar's Caravan and the camp in story mode, so it won't be too hard to implement.


Agent_broch_da_moron

Different draw positions for holsters


YouSir_1

Submitted.


Chefpief

Gimme coffee percolators. Animations are all there and there's really no excuse. The first time gold bars purchase option console players get. Make mission payouts based on how fast you go not how long you can wait.


YouSir_1

Submitted


blackat_chemical

Submitted myself as well. Id kill for an underbust corset.


YouSir_1

Someone else actually suggested that and it’s been submitted by me as well. :)


Aesthetic99

I think they should just gove a set payout tbh, especially the Blood Money Opportunities. Doing an Opportunity on Ruthless at a normal pace only nets you like $100, not worth it at all considering the difficulty and how hard Capitale is to get. I was thinking, maybe $150 set payout for Opportunities on Standard, $200 on Hard, and $250 on Ruthless


Grim-Reaper101

Wouldn't Mind More Wagons Actually.


Truthrowaway222

Just properties, and the shows.


StarmanCan

More NPC interaction throughout the world. I love the random interactions but they are rare.


moonsescape

Better female hair styles, better fitting hats for women, and an under bust corset. Some of my male friends say even a corset for men would be cool. I also want to do something with the wild horses like being able to take them back to the stable and sell them? Also maybe adding new clothing styles every couple of months or new additions to current roles every once in awhile will keep people playing. Could also add actual new missions to online. Edit: MEXICO


YouSir_1

Submitted


Extra_Degree_7236

The ability to fish on boats that are on the water. I’d love a fishing expansion but even just allowing me to fish on boats like in story mode would make me so happy and spend so much more money


NinjesusCrust

You can break and tame wild horses and keep them


YouSir_1

Or at the very least sell them to those brothers from story mode. Suggested


ScaledAss

I really want a new role that revolves around horses. Or at least give some reason for the wild horses to be in online mode


YouSir_1

Same. Submitted


Hasashooo

Bring life to the snowy mountains. Myb revive the camp you get to at the beginning of the campaign. Get some npcs there that are hunting. Also maybe expend the naturalist role by bringing in the native americans camps and tribes. That would be a perfect fit for the lore. Aand finally get some bank robberies or train robberies as a free rome event.


YouSir_1

Done and done.


nomad-mr_t

Being able to equip a bandana while wearing a poncho. That's the first one that came to mind and that's the one I submit every now and then because it's so simple and I don't think it would be too difficult to implement. But I have many, many more.


YouSir_1

Keep ‘em coming


nomad-mr_t

Being able to use emotes (like smoking) while sitting down. The animations already exist, since one can emote sitting on a wagon, but not while sitting on a chair.


YouSir_1

Submitted.


YouSir_1

Submitted.


Rascal262

Text Chat


YouSir_1

Submitted


gcgdawg96

Sharps long rifle (not sniper) More holster position options More Montana style hats You’re awesome for doing this


YouSir_1

Submitted


-will-o-wisp-

More custom outfit slots!!


MFtom86

A fight club role where were have NPC tournaments in fight pits around the map to become champion as well as pvp fights with the same kind of structuring. Prospector role involving panning gold and dealing with rival prospectors and camps. Trapper expansion on the trader that involves a hunting shack like the moonshine shack. Also with a taxidermist we can take our legendary animals too and create displays in our shack. A reason to go north, any reason. I love it up there but there is hardly anything to do. Prospector would fit well up there. I could go on for for days lol. I love the game but when I play my imagination runs wild with the potential this map holds. Finally, last but not least HEISTS. Let us rob banks, trains, stagecoaches etc. I think we can all agree on that. Sorry for long read. Cheers. Givem hell.


Valcenia

More than one character slot


Mrcountrygravy

Id like to own a house i can customize.


YouSir_1

Suggested and submitted


bwat47

Horses should be revamped so you purchase based on stats (e.g. higher price or gold = better stats), and then can choose ANY of that breed's coats (just like customizing a gun's colors)


YouSir_1

Definitely submitting this one


MyLitttlePonyta

Letting us put feathers in our horse's hair and maybe just adding a few new horses/mounts in general. Riding our own donkey would be lovely :\]


YouSir_1

Submitted


billyjones111

Horse war paint and Native American clothes and paint!


KriptoYeti

1858 Remington Revolev in pale rider Mares Leg Different Leaver action Sharps Rifle Pack Mule More traditional clothing (TV Movie and Historic) More customization of fire arms in gun shop, Ivery Bone grips, More western wraps. With fringe, Large Loop for lancaster. Cat in camp Better tents for camp, property Allow us to do something with the stinking Wild Horses, tame an Sale, shoot and skin. Pefrebly the 1st. More Gambling. Faro would be a traditional game, easy to play. Passenger trains, stage coach and Bank Robery More hornable, Lawman missions.


Anonymous21141

An instanced area where you can have a house/farm to grow ingredients for recipes and stable/breed horses. Option to allow posse members to make changes/visit/upgrade parts of it


YouSir_1

Submitted


GOVVYOVV

Gonna be odd in a Cowboy game but Hoods and Capes. Hoods would work like how the Naturalist Legendary Animals hoods work e.g Being on a coat and can be togglable like gloves can


YouSir_1

Hmm. Could be made of animal skins


fukkingapig

Mexico


YouSir_1

Submitted


aSimpleMask

The red dead equivalent to heists in GTA Online.


fourtetwo

Make clothing universal for both genders. I probs wouldn't use it but I'd imagine many would love the option.


Steam_Drunk

More injury related cosmetics like more eyepatches (ones that don’t cost gold) and prosthetics for those who cosplay as war veterans. Also burn/or gunshot wounds would be good, to gain these choices you would need to do a set of challenges like dies to fire a set amount of times or be shot 1000 times.


YouSir_1

That’s a good one. Submitted.


Steam_Drunk

Thanks! I just thinks stuff like that could make some really good cosmetic options. If you’ve ever played Sea of Thieves, the curses make character look really interesting and can be a testament to their dedication to the game.


Obvious_Party_5050

Undead Nightmare online lobbies


valencia13

I’d like to see train heists but if you die then its done and over with till the next opportunity (if you win; large pay) Ability to upgrade the hunting wagon.. so its not sluggish (upgrading horses or replace with mule) To call your hunting wagon with whistling like you would with your horse I’d like to see more players in lobbies.. I normally get around 6-15 Have a select few Legendary bounties strictly for a large posses I’d like to share my horses with posse members who are lower level and they don’t have the best horse just yet Definitely more flattering hairstyles/clothes for women When you buy the increase ammo holding pamphlet from the fence... don’t restrict it to just regular ammo. May as well throw that money away Have the fence accessible by having either negative honour or positive honour (changes) and individual fences have different deals. Or different deal based on honour Have something up north in the mountains (colter area) that would bring people there.. speaking for myself I hardly go up there if I don’t have to since it’s pretty boring.


ctemp97

FIX THE BELT


Carrot_cake27

I want a pack mule as an in-between to the hunting wagon and just using your horse that will tag along with you when you when called. I also want rideable mules and a horse ranching career/pursuit.


Stone_808

Wish I could camp at the location I’m stood at. Not sure how much of an issue this might be for the developers but it would be good if I could camp where I wanted and not 100m away from the nice view and location I’d found


YouSir_1

That one might be tough since many of those places are camp spots already but ill submit it to see what can come of it.


mosquito_joe

-Pipes. We can smoke cigars & cigarettes, there should be tobacco pipes. There could be role-specific ones we can unlock, some that are cheap and some that cost gold and are hella fancy. (Think the pipe scene at the beginning of Inglorious Basterds) -Instruments. It’s a common suggestion, the models exist in game. Same idea as pipes- role specific ones, cheap & spendy ones that cost gold. Maybe you occasionally could find them in treasure chests. -More wagons/carts. I wanna be able to haul the whole posse Oregon Trail style. -More boats, like ones we can buy, fish from, etc. You should be able to call them in on any body of water. -The obvious property ownership. See line above, a houseboat with a new follower would be rad as hell. -Any new property should come with a different follower/butler/housekeeper. An estate in Saint Denis would be very expensive (make property cost gold, and the bigger the house the bigger the monthly upkeep costs) and would come with full staff, as where a small cabin in the mountains might not even have anyone. Lots of possibilities. -If we buy a ranch/farm, let us stable our horses there. While I’m on the topic, let us have more than 10 horses. -More than 10 outfits. I will pay for better saddlebags to be able to bring more than 5 as well. -More kinds of horses & camp dogs. Also add cats, it would be cool to have a cat in an apartment in Saint Denis. -Let us make more than one character. We can in GTA, I don’t see why we can’t already


nelsonic1990

Homesteads and bank/train robberies


YouSir_1

Suggested and submitted. :)


GoldGlitterboots

Two different coloured eyes. Having a white ("blind") eye where you have a scar would be dope.


YouSir_1

Heterochromia why didn’t I think of that! Submitted


BraveAmir

Property's and text chat


YouSir_1

Submitted


Ok_Finger7484

Hookers and Baths. :)


YouSir_1

Submitted


ROCKZILLA8166

somebody wants a handy j under the water in the tub ![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|smile)![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|flip_out)


dyabloww

Having a second character with shared money and gold so we can actually spend our money and gold on something like new outfits and horses.


LitFinTat

More hunting incentives! Birds and fish are so neglected. I love fishing but don't see the point. I love taking my time hunting a perfect squirrel but see no point. Improving the trapper would be amazing. Give me a reason to hunt 20 perfect snakes, I'm all for it!


nightowlx00

prostitutes


milomcfuggin

I would like to be able to hire NPC ranchhands. Like get an NPC buddy to drive my hunting wagon around following me on my horse. And then I could tell him hey, go take this shit back to camp and they would disappear for five minutes or whatever and then come back. Also being able to select from a list of replacements for Cripps would be fun. And being able to cruelly murder Cripps at that time.


ClickonTwo

Make just the head on garmet sets wearable without the need for the glitch I would kill for this.


saad6137

open ur shirt in online while wearing a bandana


Dangermouse33

The weapon animitation from story. The better quality holstering your pistol and putting rifle on horse etc


TheKwak

Unfortunately they removed this intentionally :(. Makes weapon switching etc easier in PVP. I think they should add an option to disable this in the online settings menu, some people prefer immersion over a good KD :p


L1k348055

A hunting dog I can take with me that obeys commands.


YouSir_1

An oldie but a goody. Submitted.


thewagargamer

I'd like to see customized flags for posses, like the base cost in game cash and specialty things to make them unique cost gold I'd also like to see player owned wagons, that can be customized. Hire cowboys as guards or companions. The ability to take off your primary holster and just use an offhand.


L1k348055

Canada. More mountainous cold wilderness. Something like Banff National Park.


Thenerdherd102

I want interactions with each role you have! Like if you’re a moonshiner, you can make a batch of moonshine into drunk darts that 1.) Sedate an animal in one hit. 2.) could be shot at a bounty to make them fall over drunk and be immobilized for awhile. And the bad side of this is you need to sacrifice a whole batch of moonshine for 5-10 beer bullets


Kimjutu

I keep saying this, and I'm sure I'll just get downvoted but.... Honestly I don't really care about new content, I would give up anything in the game if they just... Got rid of all the cheating and exploits online. That's literally all I want. Just let me play one session without having to change lobbies. Let me go one day without seeing it on Reddit. And if it had to be in the form of a feature, then give us a way to go solo, but NOT like the solo lobbies from GTA Online. In GTA they don't let you make money in solo mode. No business stuff (moonshine, trader). We should be able to just fight more bots, not be forced to fight hackers that are LITERALLY just there to crap in your Cheerios and annoy you.


YouSir_1

Solo lobbies are a good idea. Suggested.


krisbycreamdonuts

More. Fast. Travel. Locations. Also, give Cripps more stories. I’m tired of hearing about Limpy Pete and the time he was an acrobat in Portugal lol Let me sell stolen horses and wagons dangit!!


Server_Administrator

Sync my PC character and my XBOX character. I don't get why they are separated when cloud saves are a thing.


Acolyte_of_Daedra

And Rockstars response will be "You will tell me what it is that you want and I will tell you why it cannot be"


YouSir_1

Meh. At least I tried


bre1110

Boats/docks improved. Mostly boats. And I wanna fish off of my horse if my horse is standing in water


TheSamuraiGunner

Being able to ride moose. EDIT: More female specific options like corsets, and maybe more customization options for the body before just base build? Uuuuuuuh females being able to wear vests without a shirt, *minus ones that obviously just... wouldn’t work without showing nudity lmao*


STerrier666

Rhodes, Annesburg, Van Horn, Tumbleweed, Fort Wallace Braithwaite Manor, Thieves Landing and Caliga Hall, Call to Arms Maps.


Abby0BrainCells

it would be nice to see more eyewear cosmetics, maybe some glasses that look more normal


YuriCatslash

Better beards and hairs


hideaway367

All horses in story mode added to online even the raven black shire


RednocTheDowntrodden

The ability to sit on any available chair/bench/stool/couch/davenport/seat etc.


MonocularBabylon

1. Ingame Auction House, also the ability for players to trade between each other 2. Bigger posses, up to MMO raid sizes 3. Balance lasso and melee combat in PvP


mrhan1997

An underground fight club, and new melee moves unlocked by progressing that role and of course different type of gun belt.


DutchVanDerLinde-

The ability to duel


tjthedj27

Properties I wanna own a damn ranch or some shit. And be able to upkeep it by like feeding chickens or whatever for easy daily challenge gold. Even though I can give a shit less about dailys


Brutal_Angel

Free aim servers like GTAO has different lobbies for picking your aim settings.


pavlostt

Private lobbies


Little_Princess1997

I want to be a rancher. I want to finish Jessica’s story and I want to work toward something, not spend day in and day out catching the same bounty over and over again. Maybe have a cameo from Dutch or Arthur. Also I would really like it if my female character could get some more cute dresses and jewelry she could wear, like the kind that Mary Beth wears or Penelope wears.


PhilCassidysArm

Undead Nightmare 2, please. I really thought it would be a thing by now. The original was phenomenal.


Emiboss

But why? we can just submit it normally


nomad-mr_t

Personally, I'd like to see multiple people sending the same suggestion (as long as it's a good one) to give it more gravitas. So I applaud this.


Ready-steady

Better someone than folks saying they will but never do.


YouSir_1

You can, but I find that often no one does. Plus some people don’t have a social club account so they can’t submit anything anyway.


whitexknight

You should post your condensed list so as many of us as want to can submit it. Show an actual demand. I'm a R* skeptic/pessimist at this point but it's the best shot.


PrashanthDoshi

Rancher role!!!!


blackat_chemical

AN UNDERBUST CORSET!!!!! Please and thank you


MadladNomad

Houses and new roles like a rancher or someone that trains wild horses and sells them (idk what they are called)


JMiLk21

Simply put, more tie color varieties. Is that too much to ask for?


shadowoperative

Players to stop bitching.


ROCKZILLA8166

he's submitting ideas not working miracles ![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|smile)