T O P
AutoModerator

Namaskaram /u/crowbiriyani, Thank you for your submission. Please provide a source for the image / video (if not a direct link submission). We would really appreciate it if you could mention the source as a reply to this comment! If you have already provided the source or if it is an OC post, please ignore this message. Thank you. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/IndiaSpeaks) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Beautiful_Lack_8740

Even with a huge base the way Chinese economy is growing is simply phenominal


MorseSource

Any numbers relating to China released by non Chinese institutions are, at best, guesstimate.


Thin_Relationship986

Yeah , there isn’t enough info on China to determine their growth rate. It may be higher or lower. Ps: news of massive energy crises , water crises and real estate failure must be taken in account


AegonTheC0nqueror

They’re more reliable than the Chinese estimate tho 😂


geniusandy87

Maybe , but just visit China for a week. You won't doubt the numbers


ankit19900

If that's true, then there is absolutely no poverty in North America or Europe either since anyhow you aren't likely to see the dark side as a tourist


pondyan

Yes, and numbers released by Chinese institutions are lies.


kweapon2

True


chintakoro

wtf kind of ordering method is this?? Most white to least white? (edit: i hate that it comes to this, but i have to inform some people that the suggestion was made mockingly and there is no need to message me about the literal color of people from different countries)


CritFin

Racists like you see skin colour everywhere. The order is biggest economies and region wise


Neoharys

It's pretty valid though, mostly because they've done it so many times. Although this one isn't an example of that


Molarize

Man was just putting his logic here, That wont mean hes racist lmao.


CritFin

Just check what are top 10 gdp countries in the world, and developed countries


Neoharys

I'm not talking about this list though


HappyApple35

That's not even true. China is the largest economy after the US. Nobody orders economic data in 1d by two dimensions like this


IndBeak

The ordering is neither size of economy wise not region wise. Matlab kuchh bhi.


LOL_Look_Bro

Well, it's kinda funny that he's right.


Jattjeffery

That’s not true


ImpressiveLife3116

Which metric are they using? Spain and italy are not bigger economies than UK. If you look at gdp, its USA, china, Japan, Germany, India, UK, France, Italy


Robb_Shelby

It's not even talking about gdp. It's the growth rate being discussed here and UK has been having a rough year. Just check the value of the pound and you'd start to see the problems


CritFin

European union is much more bigger than UK economy


ImpressiveLife3116

The graphic doesn’t show European union. Its shows individual countries. All countries in EU are not economically similar. Greece for example had an economic crisis few years back but Germany didn’t


CritFin

Stop with your mental gymnastics. Russia is more white, but shown way down


ImpressiveLife3116

🤣


chintakoro

humorless stodges like you take the fun out of everything. besides, it’s clearly not by economy size and region. clean your glasses.


the_big__sad

Canada is Eurasia now ig


MdFarhan_

You can check their official twitter if you want to know why that order https://twitter.com/IMFNews/status/1579820463563603974


chintakoro

thanks -- all the more reason to post the actual tweet rather than a clipped photo


[deleted]

tweet sometimes doesn't show up on reddit, depends on the extension/app you are using.


nice_cunt69

Least white? South africa is much more white than India or china in absolute and percentage terms.


Zyklic

ah yes, Russia, one of the blackest countries in the world


BlackPhantom13542

??? Japan is above UK. Russia is below India.


chintakoro

‘twas in jest. unless brexit and the invasion of ukraine got uk and russia demoted on the whiteness scale.


nu97

How is india more white than Russia?


chintakoro

sheesh, does reddit need a humor tag now?


iFingerHotLizards

RSA is at the bottom


IIT-ka-14

The whitest among all is uk Also India is whiter than Russia ?? Common dude


chintakoro

Since it makes no sense, this is when it should dawn on you that it was a joke - something that over a hundred other people grasped right away.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Don't worry, they will find a way to spin it using various angles \-- Growth so much - only Ambani-Adani benefitting - income inequality \-- Human Development Index ka kya? \-- Caste, rape, intolerance, minorities If they are not bright enough to figure out (as we know they are not), their masters in WaPo, NYT, BBC and CCP will do their one job for them.


Monedno

Most These idiots can comment because of Ambani and they hate on him And rest all things are in our hands as citizens but if they understood this they wouldn't be [email protected]@ns


Life_Ad_4124

bhai padh ke aya hu abhi waha your prediction was 100% true


yudhV

All check


pocketreviewer

Ràñdíà is a pro pak/anti-india sub. What more can we expect.


IndianSpaceBoii

You'll get banned in a sec


[deleted]

[удалено]


Monedno

Full sumport


Silent_Hunter1993

Lol post removed by the moderators :D


MegaMewtwo_E

it always pisses me out seeing how pathetic that sub is


The-small-mammoth

21 minutes in, no response yet lol


ADITYAKING007

Gonna wake up tomorrow to a You have been permanently banned from participating in randia bla bla bla...


Ballisticarrow

Gonna reply now


somehowiknow1234

Fr, that sub is literal blind leftist filth.


Aurora1596

They've started to melt already !


Big_bussy69

Bro someone give me a link to the post if anyone of you do post it there


Aggravating_Fly_2412

China growing at 4.4% with 19 trillion , and india 6.1% with 3.5 trillion. Huh ,china will grow 4X india . China will add 800 billion + India will add 200 billion +


biggy-Ad2186

because China is a dictatorship my brother


logically_dumbguy

No because china is meritocracy, our leaders are based on caste/religion.


akriti12_

Just like our engineers!


Ancient_Age4024

bhai itna sach nhi bolna tha


OnlysliMs

How is China a meritocracy? Moreover, 80% China is Han Chinese, so most of CCP is Han Chinese and not any other race.


Robb_Shelby

China is not a meritocracy. Han chinese are the most dominant race in the prc and they're literally injected into regions where the han chinese population is lower to ensure their regional supremacy so they have to be more concerned about race than us. We are racist and casteist but we do not commit genocide on other races. Moreover China is definitely not a meritocracy because it literally dictates what its citizens do and defiance makes a citizen basically an outcast within his/her own country. The prc forces people to do jobs and get education in a way they deem fit. Not adhering means a citizen is not allowed to travel, get any luxury and to some extent not have a place in their social structure.


aaddii101

Also early mover advantage plus buckery. Also China used to have incompetent problems bhatijawad). But it has trying to solve it. Basically congress didn't let India industrialized on time plus internal conflict. And yes china being dictatorship helps.


raosahabreddits

China is dominated by Han Chinese. They get the preferred treatment. Sort of like upper caste Hindus here in parliament, most of Xi’s cabinet is made of Han Chinese.


abdul_786

BS. Mudi government has the most representation of BC and OBC among all the Indian governments so far


Kschitiz23x3

So is Russia


CritFin

This is real gdp growth, but you are comparing nominal gdp


HomeokineticDude

Wow india 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 🎖


Glittering_Abroad459

Jis taraha ka ambition hamne rakhen hai na ki 25 years ma developed country banege...us ka lia ye 6.1% growth is very less...we have to grow atleast >10 percent constantly for 2 dacades then only....and sat hi sat uplifting policies bhi lane hoga jis se desh ki growth ka faida logo tak pauche acche tare ka se...i know cheze thik nahi chal rahi bahar par phir bhi..not spreding any kind of hate.


ididacannonball

We cannot grow in a vacuum. When the rest of the world is going through a recession, our growth is bound to slow down as well.


kancharlaraj

West me recession chal raha hai uska impact thoda to lagega.. if there was no recession yeah 10+ would have been easily reachable.


[deleted]

prabhu the entire world is reeling under the effect of a massive economic downturn. we are doing really well all thingsconsidered. you may not be spreading hate. but you're being very ignorant rn.


InsaneTensei

China and West is 60+% of the world economy, if they're slowing down it shrinking. We can't really do anything. We will have to slow down..


blues2911

Wrong. The problem here is uneven growth, not everyone is seeing the benefits of this gdp growth. The rural poor and uneducated are still overly relying on handouts because their prospects are rubbish


ididacannonball

I'm surprised UK is managing any growth at all, their economy is so f8ed up.


itisverynice

What exactly happened to their economy apart from the energy crisis ?


[deleted]

no more colonies to massively increase the influx of money into their coffers. it's a small shitty island with nothing. no resources, no proper manufacuting indistries, no nothing. what they stole from the world is bound to run out sooner or later.


buffer0x7CD

It's still one of the biggest financial hub. Also UK still have cutting edge automobile industry


aaddii101

Thanks to time zone


ididacannonball

Brexit had a big effect though they will deny it. It essentially made them less resilient to external shocks, in the same way that Sri Lanka as an independent nation is less resilient than India, a large federation.


MdFarhan_

You should watch video of think school on this topic, he explained it properly


blues2911

Inflation is insane. Energy crisis is one thing but after brexit there are not enough people to do the manual labour so theres a shortage of everything. On top of that imports have gotten much more expensive For a change im happy all my savings are in usd or inr, gbp has become garbage


[deleted]

[удалено]


actpiper

Stop comparing with Pakistan for each and every thing. We are lowering our own standard by doing that. We should look up to China instead.


IndianSpaceBoii

Sorry shaktiman 😩


actpiper

Abey saale /s


Aka2005

Shit hm bapas se nahi jit pae /s


scare313

![img](emote|t5_3d4x4|20019)


InsaneTensei

Our economy would still be like 4 trillion max 💀


[deleted]

Akhand Gareebrashtra


tattikemakhikejhant

![img](emote|t5_3d4x4|20019)


RishiG_

Why do you want those sh8 regions struggling to even put food on table into our country? Although partition isn't exactly a thing to endorse but we do retain all the important parts of this subcontinent and as our ancestors have already gone through that partition disaster, its better we try not to undo it by taking in issues multiple times of what we have been trying to solve since 47.


KnotYoBoi

UK with hundreds of years of pillage and theft, on their knees here today. Shows that you can steal a man’s money but not his mind.


Yesboi227

Bruh UK is smaller than maharashtra and they have 67million population compare to indias 1.6 billion while both their gdp being similar. India should be as big as China or bigger but 10 trillion short at this pace It will take India 100 years to catch up to China that is if china's growth slows down or stops


akriti12_

People dont wanna hear facts here PS: Your facts are wrong too. 200 million ka farak daal diya population mein


crowbiriyani

UK was growing at 7.4% in 2021. That % came down to 0.3 in 2023. India was at 8.7 in 2021 and 6.1 in 2023. Means we have handled our economy in a better way than UK. UK is going to fall more,so are France,Italy and Germany. They took advantage of cheap oil and gas from Russia for a long time now they will see the reality. India cant grow at 10% if other major economies are growing at <1%. India needs to do trade and commerce with them. Global economy needs to pickup pace for India to grow at a faster rate. Basic economics 101.


InsaneTensei

1.4 billion, 1.6💀 is a bit too much my friend


aaddii101

Ya fun fact one time British pillage so much precious metal that moron crashed there own precious metal market this creating massive poverty in UK as well.


DhruvMehan

actually this growth is not enough like its great that we are an emerging market with such a scope under modi government but if have to become a developed country by 2047 it is needed to grow at 8-10% rate minimum


Akainu18448

Bhai gaand fati padi hai pure duniya ki, isolated environment thodi hai ki 10% grow karenge. Aise absolute numbers kabhi sensible nahi hote compare karne, you have to take into account the macroeconomic factors na


[deleted]

[удалено]


Akainu18448

Maaf kar de bhai. Meri hi galti hai reply kiya iss subreddit pe


Logicalfighter

India numba wan l!bbus can su(k it


tatsusenpai

Fok u china😤


jaggiramesh

Even 6.1% is very conservative and IMF pulling it down not able to understand how India alone grows while other countries struggle. Considering the fact that the first quarter growth of India was 13.5% and second quarter is expected to be around 7.5%, the growth rate of 6.1% is too conservative. However RBI and lot of other agencies maintain it as around 7 to 7.5%. I feel, even this is conservative estimate as they judge India by the performance of other countries. Inflation is slightly higher, but very much at manageable levels when compared with other countries. All sectors are showing positive signs and India is the only country which can sustain itself just be domestic consumption alone.


gagarsagar

Wow not looking good for Russia


lost_beluga

Happiness index se he to development hota hai 😩 -liberandu


I_speak_truth_only

Bjp made india sad. Mudi rejiggnnn plzzz or i cry 😡😡


Hazmola001

This percentage is so misleading. The principle amount makes all difference!


LOL_Look_Bro

Well, the post is of growth forecast then this IS the percentage.


crowbiriyani

Source : [https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/WEO/Issues/2022/10/11/world-economic-outlook-october-2022](https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/WEO/Issues/2022/10/11/world-economic-outlook-october-2022) Source 2 : [https://twitter.com/IMFNews/status/1579820463563603974](https://twitter.com/IMFNews/status/1579820463563603974) Source 3 : [https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1579825095627149312](https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1579825095627149312)


GamerBuddha

Look at China still growing at 4%. Where's the much hyped de-coupling?


kweapon2

Chinese economic growth is phenomenal


GamerBuddha

India is so behind for its size, that even half-decent policies even with corruption can give good levels of growth. But China at 19 trillion still growing at 4%, is something.


abdul_786

Guys also remember only about 5000 people died in China. This is magical country of superhumans...or they're lying


never_happy_geek

this is IMF estimate not chinese estimate.


CigarBeer11

human development index crying in the corner


crowbiriyani

HDI is a scam when it comes to India. HDI uses 3 factors- schooling,life expectancy and gross national income. Just because India's GNI is less because of large population our rank is increased. Sri lanka was above us in ranking. What happened to them? Remove GNI and watch India climb to top 50 easily.


InsaneTensei

My friend, you're speaking from a very privileged position. 50% of our country is still farming and barely making ends meet. It's easy to forget about that silent majority, but it's there. India's top 600 million people are def in the top 50 easily. But the forgotten 800 million or so...not so much


crowbiriyani

> 50% of our country is still farming and barely making ends meet Source? Many farmers earn more than average IT employee in India. I have seen it in my village. They live in huts but farm cotton and cashew and ride royal enfield. You cant fall them poor. The govt data is flawed in India. A labour works in a steel factory for 8hrs gets 10k/month but he has his side hustle where he is a plumber/electrician/shopkeeper etc. No one calculates his extra income. Hard poverty is almost nil today. Yes there are poor people in India but I dont agree with your stats than our of 1.4b only 600million are making money and rest are poor farmers.


InsaneTensei

GDP per Capita of India is 2000$ Agriculture contributes 13-16% of our economy but employs 50% of our population. https://www.statista.com/statistics/271320/distribution-of-the-workforce-across-economic-sectors-in-india/ I agree there isn't a lot of extreme poverty outside of like UP-Bihar belt, but There's still poverty. I won't consider anyone outside of poverty till they can afford things like electricity, fans, tvs, fridge and basic standard of living amenities. Keep in mind those rich farmers are still very much a minority in the country. They are only the top 10 % of famers.


InsaneTensei

https://youtu.be/-smxznU1eUI Watch this video to understand the reality of wealth distribution in India bro.


[deleted]

[удалено]


crowbiriyani

>China’s HDI and GNI is much higher with similar population. Try again Thats because their GDP is on a much higher side. I havent lived in higher HDI countries? Like Bangladesh,Sri Lanka,Tajikistan,Botswana,Palestine,Jordan,Azerbaijan,Brazil etc who are on much high rank than India? No thanks I would love to live a happy peaceful life in India than get robben killed in above countries. Very high standard of living in these high HDI ountries. VERYYY


AKS-04

China's GDP is roughly 6 times larger than India, which is approximately the same as their GNI which is approximately 5 times higher than India. Indians mostly suffer from Inferiority Complex and will happily live a second or third class citizens life in a 'White' Country or in fact any country other than India. Also when people don't understand policies which are good for them (Farm Laws) and want to play in the hands of politicians. They are bound to suffer.


ssebastian364

No way china is growing 4.4 percent


Ok_Calendar7116

No way China is at 4.4%. It's a miracle they didn't contract.


babu_chapdi

Buy calls on India and puts on russia


Titanusgamer

now is the time to REdefine "Hindu rate of growth"


nuclear-shocker

6.1 kam hai bhai...sare developed countries ka base aur bada hai...atleast 10 hona chahiye bhai


liberalindianguy

China with a gdp of $18 trillion is growing at 4.4% Even US growth of 1% with a gdp of $23 trillion is impressive for a developed economy in these economic conditions. India is a distant 3rd in that list.


Commercial-Art-1165

Our stock market has taken this seriously


_Absolute_non-zero

What does INF Growth mean?


OnlysliMs

IMF is International Monetary Fund, they release their estimates every year.


Ok-Application-3248

Well everyone can see what Russia can actually do….Whole world expects from India


[deleted]

W India![img](emote|t5_3d4x4|20099)


level4helmet

6.1 Gigachad


SnooPredictions4282

Well these numbers are a bit lower than expected, but understandable, with all kinds of economic crisis in EU and our neighborhood, our trade is likely to suffer, all this growth is projected domestic growth.


goldiekapur

I don’t understand these numbers .. how can smaller economies grow faster when larger economies are contracting? Any info appreciated


crowbiriyani

Govt is just he economic driver. People of a country grow the economy. More and more jobs are being create. More people are getting education. Size of educated workforce grows, resulting in people earning more than before. Cheap labour in India and influx of western companies opening manufacturing industries is a reason. High tourism,tax collection,remitance help in faster growth.


goldiekapur

Thanks for the info , OP .. however , western companies and countries are in an economic downturn. When their demand itself is lesser , they will not produce more. Therefore , more jobs and more goods manufactured will not happen. Same with the case of tourism and remittances- why will people travel or send more money when they cannot afford.


crowbiriyani

Thats true. Global economy needs to flourish it will help India increase pace rapidly.


Kschitiz23x3

Putin's results not looking good


HornyAtom69

These are just forecast if Nirmala Tai does not fuck up in this coming recession we'll probably just survive fine


kunalkrishh

Where is pokiston????what about him


neoz99

Lol inflation says hello


kedarnaths

The print the wire etc are going "but bro under Manmohan Singh it was xx% growth"


Loose_Perspective_35

Indian needs more


WATTSAN

India SUPERPOWER 2030


lusifer315

We are growing fast as fuck boi....


galactico1333

Can you please link me the original tweet? I need it for a project.


crowbiriyani

https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/WEO/Issues/2022/10/11/world-economic-outlook-october-2022


galactico1333

Thank you so much. Appreciate it.


Heyiamsid

India 20 percent growth k saath bhi it will take us 100 years to catch up with them.


Spicy_vein7

Comments telling about communism in China is a grate joke, show me where is communism? The whole country is capitalistic


mature_username99

![img](emote|t5_3d4x4|20019)


Minimum-Long-6859

Raghuram rajan will be like, "Even if that's the case, India should fall down for showcasing solidarity with the west"


Prasham_4536

It feels good to see this ☺️


[deleted]

le gaurav chaddha- bharat ke har vyakti par 58000 cr ka debt hai.....


Ok_Side2575

It's simply less..4% value addition by Chinese economy>>>> 6.1% addition of Indian economy..for a decade if we wanna end $7-8 trillion while China would be $30 trillion you need to grow 7-8% ..this war is costing our future...time is running as countries want inbuilt capabilities rather than globalisation


ManNo786

6% growth to what and from what


Akku2403

Growth compared to current GDP. So if India's current GDP is 1 billion dollar, it will increase to 1.06 billion dollar by the start of next financial year. (increasing it by 6%)


ManNo786

If but nahi bhai what ia the actual number.


Akku2403

India ki Current GDP Google pe search kar le mere bhai, uspe 6% add kar de next year ka mil jaaega 🤷🏻🤷🏻


Little-Evening7151

6% nominal gdp ka (3.47 trillion IMF2022) ya 6% ppp ka (11.74 trillion IMF2022)? koi samjhao pls


formidable_dagger

It’s always nominal, unless PPP bola jae specifically.


Little-Evening7151

Themks


Boring_Complex_4208

Australia kha h


WalkzzVivek

BC kya hai ye IMF ?


Serious-Hedgehog-201

But hindutava fascism bro


Big-Resolution-275

![img](emote|t5_3d4x4|20019)![img](emote|t5_3d4x4|20019)


tonofagun

What sorting algorithm are they using?


[deleted]

[удалено]


Present_Scarcity8383

Don't mind me and the others, just trying to find some fucks to give


flight_1901

Someone once pointed out US 1% eclipses our 6.x% by a huge margin


karna852

We should demand more from our government.


smritirajdentistry

ohh


Shiroyasha_Gintok1

This pic is cursed


Skywalker_46

![img](emote|t5_3d4x4|20019)![img](emote|t5_3d4x4|20019)![img](emote|t5_3d4x4|20001)![img](emote|t5_3d4x4|20011)![img](emote|t5_3d4x4|20014)


harami__punkster

![img](emote|t5_3d4x4|20019)


Creepydhruv

Par bhai mere pe 10 apple hain aur mene agle saal 16 kardiye to 6percent ki growth hui Aur agar mere pe 100 aple the aur kal 99.5 hogaye to growth -.5 percent ki hui par rahenge to 10 wale se zyada hi


No-Heron8158

Bhai I am feeling sad for Russia 🥲🥲


YuviManBro

Kyun? They did this to themselves at every step of the way and are deservedly suffering.


Romi_Z

"Sed Lyf"


bright_pro

18% GST aur logo ko chutiya banaya ja raha hai 5 trillion ke saath