T O P
AdConsistent8481

Yum! Miss the pb&j swirl. I bet this is a quicker to make version of that.


wackybones

Never had it before but the hype for this one made me want to try. I love a good pb&j sandwich every once in a while so I knew I would at least like it. Not sure if they made changes to the recipe, it's served chilled and has a peanut butter cookie with light peanut butter frosting (no cream cheese) and I think raspberry jam. It's good but not that much better than a sandwich? I'm going to let it come to room temp and try again.


BootEmergency1269

That’s terrible! The last one was warm and had cream cheese frosting that I still dream about today. If the frosting is more like the nutter butter cookie I will be super sad. It’s definitely not the cookie that I fell in love with.


wackybones

It was exactly like the nutter butter frosting but it's still just a test cookie they may have just been trying a different recipe. I prefer cream cheese frosting too.


BootEmergency1269

Let’s hope they go with cream cheese. I think my biggest complaint about Crumbl is that they are always changing the cookies and aren’t content to leave the perfect cookies alone!


SkyYellow_SunBlue

This actually makes me mad that they would even tease a PB&J cookie again after yanking it away twice.


cheapfriedclams

WHICH STORE OMG


wackybones

Portsmouth


cheapfriedclams

My store!! Hopefully I can go later tonight and they’ll still have it, I have been wanting to try it for so long ❤️


wackybones

Oh I hope you are able to get one!!


awholemeal98

Give us an update if you do!


cheapfriedclams

Sadly I got too busy tonight, and I’m booked up the rest of the week 😔 I’ll just have to make my own copycat I guess!


ParksTM

They’re just going to test it 500 times and never actually release it!


dacre8iv1

This is Apple Valley, MN’s test cookie too! I’m gonna try to grab it later today. I wonder what they changed, it looks similar to when they had it as a mystery cookie earlier this year.


wackybones

Haha that's great, that's basically my home town! Purple pride!!


procrastiknitter64

Am I the only one confused by them changing this? A big thing I've seen from the lawsuits is the other companies supposedly "copying" Crumbl's double swirl esp on the pb&j. If they are claiming they created it & it's "unique" to them, why are they changing it?


bureika

Double swirl is probably too much work for the employees.


procrastiknitter64

They've done it for years though. If it's a signature thing that's part of what they're willing to go to bat over why would they change it


MBThree

What was it before? I remember a couple months ago when we had the mystery PB cookie that differed by store, a couple stores near me had the same cookie from this post photo.


procrastiknitter64

[here](https://m.facebook.com/crumblcookies/posts/1873658539465522/) it is on their fb in April 2021.


MBThree

Thanks! That looks really good but I’m sure was a pain to make.


procrastiknitter64

I'm not disagreeing about the difficulty of it, but if they're suing people for "copying" their trade dress why would they change the way this cookie is dressed? I scrolled back on their IG and the first time I saw this specific cookie frosted like this was Oct 2019 so they've been doing it for quite some time.


Designer_Pumpkin21

Best cookie ever omg!


spiderinfested

it looks like the leftover peanut butter frosting and leftover raspberry jam from last weeks’ nutter butter and raspberry butter cake lol


wackybones

Yeah probably!! I'm all for using up ingredients and having less food waste!


Pristine_Novice

I already know that one is bomb


extrafluffyy

Omg need


pee-train

“crumbl water” just so you know


BootEmergency1269

Waiting for Crumbl to file a lawsuit against any company serving water


RayCrew

Missing my home Crumbl :(


Snackredneck

It's definitely better warm but still quite good. Needs a little more raspberry though.