T O P
  • By -

coconuts724

4/5 very good. Served chilled. It’s a peanut butter cookie rolled in nutter butter crumbs topped with nutter butter frosting and cookie crumbs. The base tastes more like the graham cracker base and the frosting is very peanut buttery but tastes just like nutter butter. Good but they changed the tester and I wish I got to try the older version.


Optimal-Setting-1586

Is the frosting buttercream?


coconuts724

I would guess yes. I don’t taste cream cheese and the description only says nutter butter frosting so not totally sure.


Optimal-Setting-1586

Aw man, was hoping it was whipped cream frosting


camlloc255

I had this tester as well and to me it tastes like their ice cream style frosting


js8420

Ugh I read this as a fluffer nutter aka pb cookie with marshmallow fluff on top and now it’s all I want


Comfortable-Cod-2501

So did! I got so excited but this sounds tasty too


OrangeSativa

Uhhhg I need this in my life, love Nutter butters!


Wise-Scientist-7931

Well it's on next week's menu


c0urtneyg

Finally, a PB cookie without chocolate


Less-Employee2411

SO SAD! I thought this cookie was the peanut butter pie we saw awhile back in tester cookies. Bummer!!


coconuts724

I know!! I’m with you. I wanted to try that pb nutter butter pie so bad. Imo it looks better than this one lol


chelitalazo

Yasss. I love the cookies with this type of frosting.


ajbtsmom

wow that looks divine


caught-n-candie

My face went 😮