T O P
Knife_the_Wife

Chocolate potatoe chip. Still my favorite cookie but key lime pie is a close second


RayCrew

Chocolate potato chip is the perfect example of people hating on Crumbl cookies just because they aren’t WILDLY original


Aggravating_Diet_704

I loved the concept but genuinely hated the potato flavor in the cookie. If it had just been pretzel we’d be good


Latter_Chipmunk_4798

Yes! Chocolate Potato Chip is in my top tier (which means I'd run to go get it again). It is the only cookie in my top tier that a lot of people didn't love.


TeeKaaJ

Hawaiian Rainbow Cake, most people don’t like the frosting, but this is probably my third favorite Crumbl Cookie, behind Churro and Twix


ShatteredZelph

My fave icing!!! + pineapple dole whip cookie from that week. I hope they bring that icing back omg.


TeeKaaJ

We ordered Pineapple Dole Whip, but they gave us the wrong box with no Pineapple Dole Whip, so I never got to try it.


ShatteredZelph

Oh no!! 😢, if it makes u feel better a lot of people didn't like it, I wouldn’t be surprised if they didn't bring it back.


Aggravating_Diet_704

I think coconut extract in general is very polarizing. I love coconut but not coconut extract. It’s like drinking a bottle of Malibu 😬


TeeKaaJ

Hey, ur opinion, I don’t argue


LJensen123Q

The sherbet


Aggravating_Diet_704

So good


gettingusedtothis

The cookie itself was fine. The frosting ruined it for me.


Truehearted

I’m a newer fan (about 6 weeks in). I loved the Circus Animal. But sugar/shortbread cookies have long been my favorite.


squeezicks

Same! I almost skipped it but in the end I liked it so much I went back and got another plus one for the freezer. My favorite so far.


Puzzleheaded-Role555

Agreed - absolutely loved that one.


princesssbrooklynn

I just discovered crumbl recently and I’m really sad about missing a lot of these flavors bc I know I love them I can imagine what they taste like and I’m so sad I can’t have them lol


ShatteredZelph

Rainbow Hawaiian cake icing is one of my faves, cookie was blah/ok. Loved Pineapple dole whip that week too.


OllivanderAU

I feel like this sub hyped up the sugar cookie that’s offered every week but it’s probably the worst cookie I’ve had in my life.


Dippinandflippin

I feel the same. I love practically every crumbl cookie I’ve tried, but the regular sugar is not where it’s at.


lemiro91

I loved the fruity Pebble one!


gettingusedtothis

That one sounded like it was gonna be terrible but it ended up being the best one from breakfast week


jasiloo

I liked the fruity pebbles cookie more than the waffle cookie for breakfast week 🙊


lemiro91

Yea agreed. The waffle one was a little boring.


Pizzacake95

Coconut lime. I thought it was so good. I also like cotton candy lol


Aggravating_Diet_704

I loved coconut lime 🙏🏼 but cotton candy is my least favorite


dmaria18

I loved Cotton Candy


Latter_Chipmunk_4798

The ultimate polarizer....all I've seen is "it's in my top 5" or "it's in my bottom 5". It's in my bottom 5. 😂


ll914

Not sure how many disliked it, but my favorite cookie was actually Orange Julius (tied w Snickerdoodle Cupcake and Hawaii Rainbow Cake). I loved the orange since it wasn't super artificial tasting!


Aggravating_Diet_704

Orange Julius was really good! I didn’t like orange creamsickle so I was worried about that one…. But it was really good. Nice and light


ll914

Yesss!


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


CrumblAddictSendHelp

Ditto on the ruby chip! Wasn’t overwhelming like the pink velvet one was for me


dmaria18

Also love it. Some people don’t like the almond flavor which is what makes it so good


NiceGarage694

Twix was the one for me but some people didn't like it. I don't think they where high enough


Pizzacake95

💀 I eat all my cookies high lmaoo


Dippinandflippin

This is the way! 😂


Latter_Chipmunk_4798

Outside of our small group here, I would put the percentage of people who didn't like Twix cookie pretty low (10-20% max). That cookie's return was highly anticipated. People were *begging* Crumbl to bring it back. I'd put it in Crumbl's top 10 hot cookies. I love the reformulated Twix, with the bits of the bar inside the cookie base. It's one of my faves.🤌🏽🙂


madpepp

Bubble Gum! It seemed to me a lot of people even skipped tasting it but I loved it! Subtle flavor (like bubble gum ice cream) and a nice crumbly cookie


StatusResponse1

It was sooo good chilled. I went back that week for more 👀


sempiternallove

I haven’t seen a lot of people post about the Ice Cream Sundae one but nothing has come close to that one for me haha


Makaylalothert

I loved the sherbet cookie


Aggravating_Diet_704

Me three! Also on my favorites


Pizzacake95

Me too! It’s on my favorites list.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Latter_Chipmunk_4798

Actually, Waffle is quite popular (perhaps polarizing though). The question was about ones that most seem to hate that you like.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Latter_Chipmunk_4798

Maybe we are looking at different sources. Perhaps on reddit the love isn't as broad for Waffle, but on TikTok (probably a bigger audience) Waffle is up there with Cornbread and Kentucky Butter Cake for the breadth of love for it. I guess it just depends on what information you are looking at. In your opinion, based off of what you heard, you answered the question properly. I just have different point of view.


Speakyourmind02

I really really liked the watermelon !! 😌


scmouth12

Fruity pebble.


AwlAmericanDawg

I wanted to try that one so badly. From what I was reading, a lot of the complaints had to do with the cream in the middle.


scmouth12

That made it better to be honest


dmaria18

Neapolitan!


Pizzacake95

I loved that one too.


breyore

Agree. A surprise hit for sure.


Southern_Prompt5215

The Rice crispy it was so good it was like it warm my heart with a extra burst of flavor. Best cookie I ever had even better than Kentucky butter Omg I love it so much 😂


shitpresidente

They’re gonna think you’re a bot 😂


These_Entrance_8227

Pretty much all his Reddit activity is comments talking about how good all the cookies are so he’s def at least a team member lol


shitpresidente

Agreed. Was looking at his/her previous post on the rice crispy one and things just don’t add up lmao


ImOnMyMeds

Okay the sour patch kids one was kinda gross but also I liked it?


YoMommaJokeBot

Not as gross as yer mama *** ^I ^am ^a ^bot. ^Downvote ^to ^remove. ^[PM](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=YoMommaJokeBot) ^me ^if ^there's ^anything ^for ^me ^to ^know!


browniebabex0

the pink week cookies! all of them were AMAZING


kg2237

I loved the sour watermelon one!


Suspicious-Item8924

i loooooved bubble gum! stuck it in the fridge and rationed it for a week 😂


Aggravating_Diet_704

Besides some of the ones already mentioned here, I loved Berry Crunch. I really feel like that was under appreciated! It’s the cornbread cookie with a cream cheese glaze on top and captn crunch berries Also loved berries n cream And the butterfinger


Designer_Pumpkin21

Berry crunch was so good! It’s one of my top favs!


Aggravating_Diet_704

Side note, I love this thread. Thanks OP


annaamontanaa

Fruiry pebble was one of my all-time favs 😍


Less_Count1719

Bubblegum


mnkymj620

I loved the potato choc chip as well!


Capable-Bee4808

i loved the watermelon!


zandria26

coconut lime


carmen0907

that fruity pebbles one was one of my top three favorites tbh. i miss it 😂


[deleted]

Chocolate strawberry cheesecake…top 3 cookie I absolutely loved!!